Ebook Free Temperament: How Music Became a Battleground for the Great Minds of Western Civilization, by Stuart Isacoff
If you get the printed book Temperament: How Music Became A Battleground For The Great Minds Of Western Civilization, By Stuart Isacoff in on the internet book shop, you may also discover the very same issue. So, you must relocate store to establishment Temperament: How Music Became A Battleground For The Great Minds Of Western Civilization, By Stuart Isacoff and search for the offered there. But, it will certainly not take place below. The book Temperament: How Music Became A Battleground For The Great Minds Of Western Civilization, By Stuart Isacoff that we will certainly provide here is the soft data idea. This is just what make you could effortlessly discover and also get this Temperament: How Music Became A Battleground For The Great Minds Of Western Civilization, By Stuart Isacoff by reading this site. Our company offer you Temperament: How Music Became A Battleground For The Great Minds Of Western Civilization, By Stuart Isacoff the most effective product, constantly as well as constantly.
Temperament: How Music Became a Battleground for the Great Minds of Western Civilization, by Stuart Isacoff
Ebook Free Temperament: How Music Became a Battleground for the Great Minds of Western Civilization, by Stuart Isacoff
Simply for you today! Discover your preferred publication here by downloading and install and getting the soft documents of the book Temperament: How Music Became A Battleground For The Great Minds Of Western Civilization, By Stuart Isacoff This is not your time to typically visit the book establishments to get a publication. Here, selections of book Temperament: How Music Became A Battleground For The Great Minds Of Western Civilization, By Stuart Isacoff and collections are readily available to download and install. Among them is this Temperament: How Music Became A Battleground For The Great Minds Of Western Civilization, By Stuart Isacoff as your preferred book. Getting this e-book Temperament: How Music Became A Battleground For The Great Minds Of Western Civilization, By Stuart Isacoff by on-line in this site can be recognized now by visiting the link web page to download. It will certainly be simple. Why should be here?
If you really want truly obtain guide Temperament: How Music Became A Battleground For The Great Minds Of Western Civilization, By Stuart Isacoff to refer now, you have to follow this page consistently. Why? Remember that you require the Temperament: How Music Became A Battleground For The Great Minds Of Western Civilization, By Stuart Isacoff resource that will offer you appropriate expectation, do not you? By seeing this internet site, you have actually begun to make new deal to consistently be updated. It is the first thing you can start to obtain all take advantage of remaining in a site with this Temperament: How Music Became A Battleground For The Great Minds Of Western Civilization, By Stuart Isacoff as well as other collections.
From now, locating the completed site that markets the completed publications will certainly be lots of, yet we are the trusted site to check out. Temperament: How Music Became A Battleground For The Great Minds Of Western Civilization, By Stuart Isacoff with easy web link, easy download, and finished book collections become our better solutions to get. You could locate and use the advantages of picking this Temperament: How Music Became A Battleground For The Great Minds Of Western Civilization, By Stuart Isacoff as everything you do. Life is always establishing and also you need some brand-new publication Temperament: How Music Became A Battleground For The Great Minds Of Western Civilization, By Stuart Isacoff to be reference constantly.
If you still need much more books Temperament: How Music Became A Battleground For The Great Minds Of Western Civilization, By Stuart Isacoff as references, visiting browse the title and style in this website is readily available. You will discover more great deals books Temperament: How Music Became A Battleground For The Great Minds Of Western Civilization, By Stuart Isacoff in different disciplines. You could additionally as soon as possible to check out guide that is already downloaded. Open it and conserve Temperament: How Music Became A Battleground For The Great Minds Of Western Civilization, By Stuart Isacoff in your disk or gizmo. It will certainly reduce you anywhere you need the book soft documents to check out. This Temperament: How Music Became A Battleground For The Great Minds Of Western Civilization, By Stuart Isacoff soft documents to review can be referral for every person to improve the skill as well as capacity.
Few music lovers realize that the arrangement of notes on today’s pianos was once regarded as a crime against God and nature, or that such legendary thinkers as Pythagoras, Plato, da Vinci, Galileo, Kepler, Descartes, Newton and Rousseau played a role in the controversy. Indeed, from the time of the Ancient Greeks through the eras of Renaissance scientists and Enlightenment philosophers, the relationship between the notes of the musical scale was seen as a key to the very nature of the universe.
In this engaging and accessible account, Stuart Isacoff leads us through the battles over that scale, placing them in the context of quarrels in the worlds of art, philosophy, religion, politics and science. The contentious adoption of the modern tuning system known as equal temperament called into question beliefs that had lasted nearly two millenia–and also made possible the music of Beethoven, Schubert, Chopin, Debussy, and all who followed. Filled with original insights, fascinating anecdotes, and portraits of some of the greatest geniuses of all time, Temperament is that rare book that will delight the novice and expert alike.
- Sales Rank: #177652 in Books
- Published on: 2003-02-04
- Released on: 2003-02-04
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 8.01" h x .60" w x 5.17" l, .70 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 288 pages
Amazon.com Review
Involving mathematics, philosophy, aesthetics, religion, politics, and physics, Stuart Isacoff 's Temperament invokes the tone of a James Burke documentary. However, the focus is not on a modern invention, but rather a modern convention: that of tuning keyboards so that every key is equally in tune--and equally out of tune.
With the existing literature tending to bog down in mathematical theory or historical tuning methods, Isacoff bravely attempts to make this seemingly arcane topic interesting to the general reader. He distills the mathematics and music theory into their simplest essences, and draws apt analogies from the everyday. He also generously peppers the text with the quirks and escapades of its more flamboyant central characters; the relevance of the information is often tenuous at best, but Isacoff has obviously done his homework, and he can be forgiven some frivolity.
Less forgivable is his neglect of "well-temperament." Namesake of Bach's masterful collection of 24 pieces (one each in all the major and minor keys), the well-tempered keyboard liberated composers from the howl of badly tuned keys in the way equal temperament did, while preserving the distinct quality of each key. It was a pragmatic and aesthetically rich solution that captivated composers and theorists for decades. Yet Isacoff reserves less than two pages for its description. (Perhaps he deliberately overlooked the topic since it doesn't fit well with his casting of equal temperament's opponents as rigid, dogmatic, and impractical.)
Despite its flaws, Temperament is an accessible guide to a fascinating topic seldom discussed outside musical circles. Though the book may not invigorate hard-core theorists, the amateur musician, armchair scientist, history buff, or plain old curious can glean plenty from it. The advent of digital keyboards--some of which can be tuned to historical temperaments at the flip of a switch--makes this an ideal time for the topic to be rejuvenated. --Todd Gehman
From Publishers Weekly
Isacoff, editor-in-chief of Piano Today magazine, tells the worthy tale of how musical temperament the familiar, seemingly fixed relationships between notes on an instrumental scale came to be taken for granted. After centuries of an accepted belief in the mathematical and divine governance of music, the 17th century saw the growth of a fierce debate over experimental new tuning methods. In the 18th century, the modern keyboard allowed for a new kind of tuning, known as equal temperament, whereby each pitch is equally distanced. New musical possibilities opened up, changing composition forever. Isacoff traces music theory contributions by da Vinci, Newton, Descartes, Kepler and Rameau. Unfortunately, he sometimes clumsily attempts to keep his audience's attention with irrelevant, if salacious, gossip e.g., philosopher Robert Hooke "recorded his orgasms in a diary," and King Louis XIV refused to eat with a fork. Meanwhile, he gives relatively short shrift to Kepler and Galileo. His ambitious historical canvas uses extensive secondary sources, but there are research gaps, such as his outdated portrait of Isaac Newton as a total "ascetic." Nevertheless, this harmonics drama will excite music geeks and music historians. (Nov. 24)Forecast: Knopf's prestige guarantees sales to major music collections, and Isacoff's national media appearances (NPR, etc.) may mean good general sales.
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Isacoff, a composer and editor of Piano Today magazine, illuminates issues surrounding the different modes of musical temperament, bringing together aspects of science, philosophy, history, poetry, religion, and music in a compact yet compelling narrative. He addresses the development of equal temperament in chapters ranging from the ancient Greek origins of Western tuning through discoveries by 16th- and 17th-century astronomers and physicists to today's composers and performers. His fascinating side paths on how the Roman Catholic Church dealt with scientific progress, the genesis of various musical instruments, his sojourns in China, and the clashes between major players such as Galileo and Zarlino add flashes of drama. The writing is geared to those with little background in music, but Isacoff's arguments can also be appreciated by informed readers. A distracting use of sentence fragments is one of the only drawbacks to this impressive effort. The up-to-date bibliography includes classics in the field and new research. Isacoff's book is a worthy complement to Owen Jorgensen's massive treatise Tuning (Michigan State Univ., 1991) and is recommended for all libraries. (Index not seen.) Barry Zaslow, Miami Univ. Libs., Oxford, OH
Copyright 2001 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Most helpful customer reviews
122 of 125 people found the following review helpful.
Why you might/might not like this book: Reviewing reviews
By P. Vogel
I thoroughly enjoyed this book and, for the first time in my life, feel that I actually understand the issues around temperament. I would recommend this book to a lot of people but not everyone, as the number of negative reviews illustrates. The negative reviews for this book seem to fall into four categories-if you are in one of those groups then you may want to buy a different book:
1) The lunatic fringe: Examples here are: The review that castigates the book for abusing non-Western music (It's hard to see the point of this complaint since the intent of the book is to discuss the role of temperament in Western music--no real mention is made of any other kind of music); The review by the person who read only a 2 or 3 page excerpt of the book (apparently ignorance is no impediment to opinion); The person who hadn't read the book yet but would post a review when they had (see previous); The reviewer who felt that the book was all about sex (I missed that). And so on.
2) People who were unhappy about the lack of technical detail. While I am obviously disparaging the previous group, these reviewers have a valid complaint. These readers were looking for (as examples): actual scores; more math with more explicit discussion of the exact size of the differentials between similarly named tones; more technical terms (e.g. "hertz"). I have a good grounding in math, read a lot of technical material, but would probably best be described as a "music lover". I'm just not in these reviewers league. Since I don't read music, for instance, a score would be useless to me. For the audience that I represent, the level of technical detail worked very well and is appropriate for a "general interest" book. The author's description of the music met my needs and the prescence of a score wouldn't have helped. I didn't miss the technical details that these other readers were looking for.
3) Reviewers who felt a lot of the book was irrelevant and fluff. Also a valid comment as much of the book isn't directly about temperament (as an example, these reviewers would probably point to chapter 7, which is an overview of the birth of the Renaissance). However, the author's intent is not to discuss temperament but to discuss how the battles over temperament reflected much of what else was going on politically and culturally at the time. He wants to claim that the discussions of temperament reflected other battles and that the arguments over temperament were enabled only by other changes going on in the world. If that larger discussion doesn't interest you, this is the wrong book for you in the same way that the lack of technical detail made the book an unhappy experience for the previous group of readers. Again, I enjoy the kind of writing that tries to draw connections between relatively obscure technical matters and larger social interests. However, it does mean that this isn't a book that is just about temperament.
4) People who wished the author had gone into more detail/covered more topics. As examples: Apparently well-temperament has gotten short shrift (I can see that I would have liked more on the topic); The book focuses on the issues as demonstrated by tuning pianos (the author announces this early in the book); Some readers would have like more on temperament issues with other kinds of instruments; other readers wished the author had followed up on reference to temperament in China, organs, and other topics. Apparently there is room here for a larger book on this topic. I enjoyed the length of the book and it didn't leave me wanting more but that may just reveal my ignorance of the subject: Had I known more I may have wanted more.
If you are looking for a medium-length discussion of temperament (a critical topic in understanding music) for the general reader and music lover, a book that tries to tie this topic into the larger cultural/political/social changes in the world--then this is a fascinating book. It's well written (a couple of stretched metaphors) and interesting (I devoured it in two days). If you are looking for a broader study, a more technical discussion, or a discussion of temperament purely in musical terms then you will be disappointed. I got excited about the topic! The book made me want to buy a CD that demonstrates the issues by playing the same piece of music in several different tunings--something that I wouldn't even have considered before.
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful.
Interesting subject, unsatisfactory treatment
By A Customer
The book is too anecdotal, an amateurish cultural history. Many of the materials are not quite relevant. If the author stuck to the subject the pages could be two-third less. Hope someone will come up with a better one.
32 of 36 people found the following review helpful.
An entertaining read
By D. Catherino
A good superficial read on the historical development of 12 tone equal temperament. For a more in-depth and analytical look at temperament I would recommend Harry Partch's Genesis of a Music.
A word of warning, this book is available under 2 titles. Temperament - the idea that solved music's greatest riddle, and Temperament - how music became a battleground for the great minds of western civilization. I purchased both assuming that they were companion works, but they are identical.
Temperament: How Music Became a Battleground for the Great Minds of Western Civilization, by Stuart Isacoff PDF
Temperament: How Music Became a Battleground for the Great Minds of Western Civilization, by Stuart Isacoff EPub
Temperament: How Music Became a Battleground for the Great Minds of Western Civilization, by Stuart Isacoff Doc
Temperament: How Music Became a Battleground for the Great Minds of Western Civilization, by Stuart Isacoff iBooks
Temperament: How Music Became a Battleground for the Great Minds of Western Civilization, by Stuart Isacoff rtf
Temperament: How Music Became a Battleground for the Great Minds of Western Civilization, by Stuart Isacoff Mobipocket
Temperament: How Music Became a Battleground for the Great Minds of Western Civilization, by Stuart Isacoff Kindle
No comments:
Post a Comment